“Grumpy and curmudgeonly”

Is this our destiny?

In my late 30’s/early 40’s, a discussion question posed to my singing group was, “How would you describe yourself; as wind, water, earth or fire?” Next, we were encouraged to ask our partners, or someone who knew us well, how they would describe us? My friends all defined me as ‘water,’ while I was not convinced. I believed myself to be ‘fire,’ to their surprise. Before I could even finish posing the question to my husband, he replied, without hesitation, “Fire.”

A saying has been passed down through generations of my husband’s family that “as you get older, you don’t change, you just get ‘more so.’ We revisit this thought at times when it seems older friends and family members are becoming more extreme in their views on just about everything. Contrarily, I believe myself to be much more tolerant, even-tempered, logical, and less quick to judge than in my youth. My ability to learn from my mistakes is possibly what I like best about myself. Today, in my 50’s, I truly believe myself to be less ‘fire’ and more ‘water’. I believe I have changed for the better but apparently, I am not alone in this personality change.

As reported in this BBC Future article, a research team from the University of Edinburgh reported that our personalities exhibit progressively positive changes by the time we reach our 70’s and 80’s. It’s an interesting article including anecdotes from Ronald Reagan and studies dating back to 1932. I will be severely paraphrasing so be sure to read the full article for the details if you are interested. In summary, between our 30’s and 70’s, we gradually become:

  • More conscientious
  • more trusting
  • more willpower
  • have better sense of humor
  • more emotional control
  • and overall nicer and less neurotic (I’m particularly fond of this last one.)

Hooray! Positive things associated with aging and things that are consistent worldwide, across all cultures and good for the health. However, there is more to this story. Even though our personalities shift in a positive direction as we age, they remain relatively constant. In other words, “the most neurotic 11-year-olds are generally still the most neurotic 81-year-olds.”  (My bubble deflating slightly). Furthermore, there is a reverse shift that occurs between late 70’s and 90’s. This is completely understandable to me. I remember listening while my mother-in-law read the obituaries. She had outlived all her friends and yes, she was very grumpy about it. Once, our youngest won a state-wide photography contest with a close up of her face. As a winner, it traveled all around the state to be seen by LOTS of people. She was horrified. We took her to see it while on display in our town. As soon as she caught a glimpse of it, she started grumbling, “I look 108 years-old! (She was in her 80s) People are staring! What must they be thinking?” My response, “They’re probably thinking you look pretty good for 108.”

A very strong woman of the greatest generation. She believed in education and equality for all when many people did not.

In my personal experience, there seems to be another positive shift in centenarians. People I’ve met in their late 90s and 100’s have all been so happy, gentle and kind, often taking no medication, and generally don’t look a day over 75. Maybe they’ve just outlived all the curmudgeons or maybe it’s their impeccable health that has kept them alive so long? When I’ve asked how they stay so young and healthy, the replies ranged from homegrown fruits and vegetables, never drank alcohol or smoked, to hard work and prayer. And when questioned about their lack of wrinkles, the replies ranged from Vaseline, Dove soap, Ponds and Oil of Olay. Those conversations always brought a smile to my face as I thought to myself, they must have great genes!

The good news is even though data seems to suggest we might be genetically hard-wired to mature as we age, the rate at which we mature is still flexible. It’s good to know all the self-reflection and awareness training has not gone to waste. I’m willing to bet the stereotypical ‘grumpy old curmudgeon’ did not devote much time to the self-improvement section in the book store. We can do this. Just say, “No” to becoming the grumpy old curmudgeon.


Earth Photo by Ivan Bandura on Unsplash

 Water Photo by David Becker on Unsplash

Fire Photo by Cullan Smith on Unsplash

Wind Photo by Christian Wiediger on Unsplash

10 thoughts on ““Grumpy and curmudgeonly”

Add yours

  1. Great post! I was very shy and quiet when I was young but as I aged I became more confident and able to converse with most people and lost my fear of going new places alone. I am more patient, kinder..etc. I am still the same underneath it all but cope so much better. It could be my faith and trust in God too. I enjoy following your blog.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I think life experiences have an impact. I am not as trusting as I was in my 20’s and 30’s. I agree, faith, patience and kindness are great goals, add in forgiveness to help us not be bitter and angry. Love your blog. Nice post.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. So true as we get older we change into different people. Whether we get “better” or “worse” I think depends on how accepting we are of the whole aging process and our past experiences.


  4. I’m 58 and in my experiences, grouchy old people were once grouchy young people. These are the type that never admit they were wrong, never grow, and surround themselves with “yes” men. Some people just love to be a big fish in a small pond. Me, I’d rather be a small fish in a large pond, ideally an ocean. This is how you grow, by being humble, by admitting your mistakes (even if they are not necessary regrets), and on a constant quest to learn. My husband and I are both this way and very, very happy with each other, and in life. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Will be 73 in June. I have less confidence in myself. No longer adventurous or a risk taker. Expect one difficulty or challenge arriving in the mail several times a week. Getting more comfortable with the prospect of my own death as life is wearing me out. Am very disappointed I feel this way and angry at the reasons for it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Apparently you are not alone, Carl. It saddens me you and majority of people in 70-90 age group feel this way. Especially you with all the humor and joy you’ve shared with the world over the years. I, too, feel that worn out in my 50s as I deal with chronic pain from degenerate joint disease and the isolation over the past 2 pandemic years. There must be some way to combat these feelings. I believe finding a counselor who specializes in geriatric populations, as well as, finding a more positive-minded group of friends in your age group is beneficial. Personally, volunteerism has made a huge difference. I know lots of volunteers in their 70s who become involved in social organizations or volunteer at libraries, animal shelters, zoos, etc. Helping others is very rewarding. I can think of so many ways your creative skills could be put to good use!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

Observations of a Human Person

motherhood, business, kids, people


Short reads on the mixed tides of human nature.


30 YEARS DOWN forever to go! (Roadtrek SS Agile)

This Is My Thing

I am challenging myself to try something new each month in 2022 + then I write about it here. New posts every Friday ✍

Word of the Day Challenge

Alternative haven for the Daily Post's mourners!

Empish J. Thomas

Freelance Writer, Disability Blogger and Accessibility Consultant. I write and blog about #Accessibility #AudioDescription #Blindness #Disability and #Reading

~Plucking Of My Heartstrings~

Blogging on a variety of things that pluck at the hearts' emotions & more

Books of Brilliance

The latest book reviews and book news

Cherie White

Author and Anti-Bullying Advocate

Welcome to Your Life!

Midlife Made Easier

Something to Ponder About

Musings on Life - Creative Writing - Environment

Motown Savvy

Fun, Fashion, Frivolity: An insider guide to Metro Detroit and beyond

My Memory List

Living Life. Making Memories.


The blog of Academe magazine

%d bloggers like this: